Showing posts with label Groundwater Wars Poland Springs Pierce Atwood SAPPI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Groundwater Wars Poland Springs Pierce Atwood SAPPI. Show all posts

Friday, January 2, 2009

Formal Complaint Sappi violation

December 29, 2008

Ms. Kimberly D. Bose, Secretary
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
888 First Street, NE
Washington, D.C 20426

Re: Eel Weir Dam Project No. 2984 ME Response to Letter of Tom Howard
December 15, 2008
Accession number 20081215-5143 p-2984-074
Formal Complaint


Dear Secretary Bose,

SD Warren states on page two “There were no reported or observed adverse environmental impacts as a result of the lake level being above the applicable target line during the periods described in this report. No comments or communications were received from the resource agencies regarding the lake level during the period covered by this report.”

I will respond that, presently, due to the higher Sebago Lake water level management plans ongoing since 1989, I am forced to rock armor 400 feet of my shoreline along Long Point of Sebago Lake as specified and approved with a Maine DEP permit. I do this to protect my camp and lake access. The cost is in the tens of thousands of dollars. Because of the near unprecedented higher water for this time of year, the sixty inch wide Bobcat front loader we are using to move rock can not traverse the beach area without fully entering the water column. This encroachment is a violation of the permit thus terminating work until next November. At least two and one half vertical feet of protective cobbles, sand and vegetation on the beach against the toe of the bank is gone due to erosion since 1987. Due to the higher water levels this November and December with only near average rainfall my shoreline armoring work has been suspended. This will mean that unprotected embankment will be eroding when lake levels are forced to full pond next spring. Even at levels of more than 2 feet below the spillway, there is now no beach on Long Point.

I wish to state for the official record that these higher fall lake levels are creating an added financial burden for our family and it is damaging our shoreline. It is worrisome that any time a “tube” is not working, any of the 8 dams need repair, or a flashboard is damaged SAPPI is excused for violating the agreement regardless of their irresponsible planning. I am requesting that FERC require an additional lowering of the lake when repairs are scheduled for dams on the Presumpscot. To do these repairs in the late fall when precipitation and runoff is naturally higher and SD Warren only lowers the level to 263 on November1, which is six inches above the target, lacks responsibility. Lake levels should drop at least to the low end of the permitted range if not lower.
SAPPI’s submission of explanation failed to include Prestone information that Long Lake’s 4 foot lowering of water levels has been delayed. It appears the delay is related to the failure of Sappi to adhere to the water level license requirements. Because of the higher than average Sebago Lake levels, the gates at Songo dam can not discharge the water of Long Lake effectively. Warren fully is aware of this from over a century of experience. This will further delay the lowering of Sebago Lake.

By this letter I am filing a formal complaint against SAPPI for violating the Sebago Lake Lake Level Management Plan and for the damage and monetary losses that this reckless management has financially burdened my family.

Sincerely,
Roger Wheeler

Roger Wheeler
PO Box 561
Fryeburg, Maine
04037
email: friendsofsebago@yahoo.com

Tuesday, December 18, 2007

Poland Springs and Fryeburg Altered Hydrology Wars

Another water war rages west of Sebago Lake in the town of Fryeburg. Poland Spring is extracting water from an aquifer feeding Lovewell Pond. Residents are documenting with photographs how the pond is stagnating in the summer months and water quality has been degraded. The whole affair is a tangled mess. It is similar to Sebago Lake’s recent past in that a consultant or State official with credentials will state an erred conclusion or statement that is greedily welcomed as gospel by those reaping great profits by plundering of the resource and their conclusion are parroted without conscious for eternity.

Remember DEP’s conclusion that erosion has always been an ongoing problem on Sebago Lake and how the high water advocates and the bureaucrats latched on to this conclusion which was disproved by FERC. We learned by watching with great sadness that when SAPPI raised the average lake level and reduced the range, shoreline erosion became an ongoing accelerating problem that has destroyed the world’s finest inland lake beaches.

Lovewell Pond is an undammed lake that naturally fluctuates with the Saco River. It has very nice stable beaches. In the summer low flow months, Lovewell Pond relies on inflow from springs mostly from Wards Brook. Each year the inflow hydrology is radically altered by the extraction of high quality Ward’s Brook aquifer spring water of the amount that would fill a truck tanker sized tube of water stretching from Fryeburg to Boston and back The volume of water contained in this “tube of water” is eliminated from the Lovewell Pond ecosystem annually. Based on a consultant study this extraction is insignificant and has no impact on Lovewell Pond.
The first consultant study cited the extraction was insignificant based on statements by two local residents and one state DEP scientist. The DEP official when questioned explained the amount of extracted water was insignificant in relation to the seasonal river flood inflow to the lake. When questioned about impacts of the extraction during the low flow summer months the State official clarified that her statement was relative to annual water volume of the Pond. She did not say that the extraction would have an insignificant impact on the ecosystem and water quality of Lovewell Pond but that is what Poland Springs has falsely presented publicly. A following study by Normandeau associates has stated the same conclusions based on the first erred report by EGGI. No measurements of water flow or groundwater height apparently were made downstream from the extraction points. Poland Springs claims that they only take the “excess water”.
Similar to SAPPI, Poland Springs has used corporate threats upon a small local populace. SAPPI loves to say basically if you make us obey the Clean Water Act laws we will fire our employees. Poland Springs lawyer Pierce Atwood ( SAPPI’s Lawyers too) threatened Fryeburg with a huge lawsuit if Fryeburg does not interpret their zoning laws suitable to Nestle’s Poland Spring demands. Not happy with the local grass roots opposition , the owner of the water company who sells the towns former spring water to Poland Spring has threatened to raise the water rates of Fryeburg citizens and now is reportedly pursuing this before the PUC.
Poland Spring now armed with the Normandeau study is steadfastly advertising the consultant facts that there is no harm to Lovewell Pond.
They are deflecting claims of lake degradation citing shorefront owners and the rivers contribution. Sound familiar? Poland Spring like SAPPI has learned well from Big Tobacco tactics.